A person who was well skilled in dissection opened a bitch, and
as she lay in most exquisite tortures offered her one of her young
puppies, which she immediately fell a-licking; and for the time seemed
insensible to her own pain; on the removal she kept her eye fixed
on it and began a wailing sort of cry which seemed to proceed rather
from the loss of her young one than the sense of her own torment.
Joseph Addison (1672-1719)
An infallible characteristic of meanness is cruelty. Men who have
practised tortures on animals without pity, relating them without
shame, how can they still hold their heads among human beings?
Samuel Johnson (1709-1784)
A course of experimental physiology in which brutes are agonised
to exhibit facts already established, is a disgrace to the country
that permits it.
John Elliotson, MD, FRS (1791-1868)
I despise amd abhor the pleas on behalf of that infamous practice,
vivisection. I would rather submit to the worst of deaths, so far
as pain goes, than have a single dog or cat tortured on the pretense
of sparing me a twinge or two.
Robert Browning (1812-1899)
The Queen has done all she could on the dreadful subject of vivisection,
and hopes that Mr. Gladstone will speak strongly against such a
practice which is a disgrace to humanity...
Queen Victoria (1819-1901)
The excuse or toleration of cruelty upon any living creature by
a woman is a deadly sin against the grandest force in nature - maternal
love ... In not a single instance known to science has the cure
of any human disease resulted necessarily from this fallacious method
of research.
Elizabeth Blackwell (1821-1910)
What I think about vivisection is that if people admit that they
have the right to take or endanger the life of living beings for
the benefit of many, there will be no limit for their cruelty.
Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910)
I am not interested to know whether vivisection produces results
that are profitable to the human race or doesn't...The pain which
it inflicts upon unconsenting animals is the basis of my enmity
toward it, and it is to me sufficient justification of the enmity
without looking further.
Mark Twain (1835-1910)
The discovery of the law of evolution, which revealed that all
organic creatures are of one family, shifted the centre of altruism
from humanity to the whole conscious world collectively. Therefore,
the practice of vivisection has been left by that discovery without
any logical argument in its favour.
Thomas Hardy (1840-1928)
There are many more eminent men in my profession who are adverse
to vivisection than who are in favour of it.
L.Forbes Winslow, DCL, MB, LLD, MCRP (1844-1913)
If, as we know, the creatures with fur, feathers or fins are our
brothers in a lower stage of development, then their very weakness
and inability to protest demands that man should refrain from torturing
them for the mere possibility of obtaining some knowledge which
he believes may be to his own interests.
Luther Burbank (1849-1926)
I have always felt that the cause of science cannot possibly be
served by cruelty to animals, and especially by the barbarous practice
of vivisection.
Robert Howell Perks, MD, FRCS, LRCP (1854-1929)
Atrocities are not less atrocities when they occur in laboratories
and are called medical research.
George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950)
Vivisection is a social evil because if it advances human knowledge,
it does so at the expense of human character.
George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950)
Vivisection, for the purpose of class demonstration as practised
abroad, cannot be too severely condemned. I am quite convinced that
even at the present day in these islands an immense amount of needless
and absolutely purposeless suffering is caused to dumb animals by
so-called scientific enquiries.
Sir Thomas Myles CB, MD, FRCSI (1857-1937)
We ought not to ridicule the pretensions of the anti-vivisectionists
- the sufferings of animals are truly horrible; and sympathy with
them is not sentimentality.
Vikenty Veressayev (1867-1945)
Vivisection is the blackest of all the black crimes that a man
is at present committing against God and his fair creation. It ill
becomes us to invoke in our daily prayers the blessings of God,
the Compassionate, if we in turn will not practise elementary compassion
towards our fellow creatures.
Mohandas Gandhi (1869-1948)
Let none count themselves wise who have not with the nerves of
their imagination felt the pain of the vivisected.
John Cowper Powys (1872-1963)
Scientific civilisation has destroyed the soul of the world.
Alexis Carrel, MD (1873-1944)
During my medical education at the University of basle I found
vivisection horrible barbarous and above all unnecessary.
Carl Jung (1875-1924)
To fight against vivisection is to fight against the principal
fortress of the foe of idealism and spiritual evolution. Not until
this fortress be shattered, and even its ruins removed from the
face of the earth, can we justly claim to possess civilisation.
Emilia Lind-Af-Hageby (1878-1963)
Knowledge acquired in biological research is seldom directly applicable
to human beings ... The results of scientific research, obtained
under these conditions, cannot be applied directly to human beings
who vary widely in their hereditary make-up, in their environment,
and in their past health record.
Lord (John) Boyd Orr, CH, FRS, LLD (1880-1971)
Vivisection is mostly undertaken in the expectation that the goal
which has been mentally erected is attainable. The results never
justify the means as erecting goals is an idle pursuit, as evidenced
by research conducted on these lines retarding instead of advancing
progress.
James McDonagh FRCS (1881-1965)
Even should it be conclusively proved that human beings benefit
directly from the suffering of animals, its infliction would nevertheless
be unethical and wrong.
Air Chief Marshall, Lord Dowding (1882-1970)
Most experts agree that animal testing today is virtually pointless.
As one clinical director puts it: "You cannot really rely on tests
with any other animal or combination of animals to predict drug
or surgical action in man."
Curtis Freshel (1886-1968)
... on account of the dissimilarity between animals and human
beings, it is worse than useless to attempt to base any methods
of treatment or prevention of human disease on animal experimentation.
Dr.M.Beddow Bayly, MRCS, LRCP (1887-1961)
Never believe that animals suffer less than humans. Pain is the
same for them that it is for us. Even worse, because they cannot
help themselves.
Dr Louis J.Camuti (1893-1981)
Terror, agony, and abominable cruelty are inseperable from the
experiments on animals at the Government Microbiological Research
Establishment at Porton Down - an Animal Belsen.
Emrys Hughes MP (1894-1969)
Vivisection can only be defended by showing it to be right that
one species should suffer in order that another species be happier
... If we cut up beasts simply because they cannot prevent us and
because we are backing our own side in the struggle for existence,
it is only logical to cut up imbeciles, criminals, enemies, or capitalists
for the same reasons.
C.S.Lewis (1898-1963)
We have a special duty to all animals and we must fight against
the merchants of animal suffering who subordinate compassion to
the heartless demands of so-called scientific progress.
Edgar Lustgarten (1907-1978)
Knowledge without pity may well be the greatest danger that besets
the world.
John Vyvyan (1908-1975)
Vivisection - a social evil that advances human knowledge at the
expense of human character.
John Vyvyan (1908-1975)
The humane acquisition of knowledge is indispensable to a civilised
society.
John Vyvyan (1908-1975)
Science ... has established a new set of values, which amounts
to the pitiless exploitation of the rest of nature for the physical
benefit of man.
John Vyvyan (1908-1975)
Vivisection is wrong because it is an abuse of man's power over
the helpless, involving pain and suffering. The name for this is
cruelty, and cruelty is immoral, no matter what the reason for its
introduction.
Jon Evans (1917- )
Most animal experimentation is useless.
Henry J. Heimlich (1920 - )
Ask the experimenters why they experiment on animals, and the
answer is: "Because the animals are like us." Ask the experimenters
why it is morally OK to experiment on animals, and the answer is:
"Because the animals are not like us." Animal experimentation rests
on a logical contradiction.
Professor Charles R.Magel (1920- )
The case against vivisection is the same as that against war and
all other forms of cruelty - that violence does not produce long-term
solutions.
Jon Wynne-Tyson (1924-
)
... the only argument against vivisection that will be seen to
have lasting power - that we do not improve human society by means
that debase human character.
Jon Wynne-Tyson (1924- )
There is conditioned brutality among scientists, especially in
the universities of Britain. The time has come to call a halt. The
situation has got out of hand.
Dr Kit Pedler (1928-1981)
A medical profession founded on callousness to the pain of the
other animals may eventually destroy its own sensibility to the
pain of humans.
Brigid Brophy (1929- )
The philosophy behind vivisection, the sacrifice of creatures
we regard as 'inferior' beings, differs little from that behind
the concentration camp or the slave trader.
Aga Khan (Prince Sadruddin) (1933- )
I do not believe that chimpanzees, rats and the rest should be
sacrificed, even for an acknowledged greater good; such sacrifice
infringes their right to refuse. In my morality, all creatures with
feelings and wishes should be thought of as ends-in-themselves,
and not merely means.
Professor Stephen L.Clark (1945- )
At present scientists do not look for alternatives simply because
they do not care enough about the animals they are using.
Peter Singer (1946- )
Once one accepts that there is something essentially different
between a dog chasing after a stick and a stone plummeting to earth,
then one will have a hard time in morally justifying for example,
why a healthy dog is given lung cancer with tobacco smoke in order
to prove something to a suicidal human who smokes forty cigarettes
a day.
Stanley Godlovitch (1947- )
|