Mary Midgley is a philosophy lecturer at the University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
Her first book, Beast and Man, deals with theoretical issues
in the relationship between humans and animals. More practically,
she has written Animals and Why They Matter, an influential
text that challenges some of the assumptions and concepts of animal
rights.
Quotes:
Mourning and desolation are not our inventions. But because we
can anticipate them, can think about them, and experience them widely
in imagination, we have a graver problem - one, of course, which
forms part of the price we pay for the joys and uses of imagination
But the way to face this problem cannot possibly be the dualist
one - the way of identifying our real selves exclusively as soul
or intellect, while drawing up the ladder that connects this aspect
with the rest of our nature. We cannot dismiss our emotions and
the rest of our nonintellectual nature, along with the body and
the earth it is fitted for, as alien, contingent stuff. We have
somehow to operate as a whole, to preserve the continuity of our
being.
This means acknowledging our kinship with the rest of the biosphere.
If we do not feel perfectly at home here, that may after all have
something to do with the way in which we have treated the place. Any
home can be made uninhabitable. Our culture has too often talked in
terms of conquering nature. This is about as sensible as for a caddis
worm to think of conquering the pond that supports it, or a drunk
to start fighting the bed he is lying on. Our dignity arises within
nature, not against it.
- Beast and Man
People in general have perhaps thought of animal welfare as they have
thought of drains - as a worthy but not particularly interesting subject.
In the last few decades, however, their imagination has been struck,
somewhat suddenly, by a flood of new and fascinating information about
animals. Some dim conception of splendours and miseries hitherto undreamt
of, of the vast range of sentient life, of the richness and complexity
found in even the simplest creatures, has started to penetrate even
to the least imaginative. For the first time in civilized history,
people who were interested in animals because they wanted to understand
them, rather than just to eat or yoke or shoot or stuff them, have
been able to advance that understanding by scientific means, and to
convey some of it to the inquisitive public. Animals have to some
extent come off the page. With the bizarre assistance of TV, Darwin
is at last getting through. Town-dwellers are beginning to notice
the biosphere.
- Animals and Why They Matter
... the colossal confidence which many eighteenth and nineteenth
century intellectuals used to feel in the absoluteness of human
dominion. To their minds, human dignity justified and depended on
a total separation of man from all the rest of creation. That's
why they got such a shock when the Origin of Species came out. Someone
who has buttressed his sense of his own dignity by allowing no dignity
at all to anybody else, naturally feels any suggestion of a relationship
with those others as intolerably degrading. The separatist Position.
- Third Opinion, Radio Three 26 June 1981
|